Every board game collection has that one game.
The one people point at the moment they walk into the room.
“What’s that?”
“Have we played this before?”
“Can we try that one tonight?”
Those are the games that earn their shelf space.
Not because they’re the most expensive.
Not because they have the fanciest box.
Because they create stories.
Inside jokes.
Friendly rivalries.
And occasionally… lifelong grudges over completely fictional events.
If you’re looking to add something new to your collection, these are six games I’d happily recommend—whether your group loves strategy, spooky mysteries or simply laughing together around the table.
Light, Fun & Instantly Playable
The games that make people say “one more round.”
Mystic Market
The “it looks cute… until everyone gets competitive” game
Running a magical potion market sounds wonderfully peaceful.
Until somebody buys the ingredient you’ve been saving for three turns.
Mystic Market is charming from the moment it comes out of the box.
Bright artwork.
Colourful ingredients.
A theme that immediately makes people curious.
But underneath all that charm is a surprisingly clever little economy where every purchase changes the market for everyone else.
You start by casually collecting ingredients.
Before long you’re watching everyone else’s turns far more closely than you’d like to admit.
It’s easy to learn, satisfying to master and one of those underrated games that deserves far more attention than it gets.
Best for: Casual game nights, families and anyone who secretly enjoys planning three moves ahead.
Betrayal at House on the Hill
The “everything was going so well…” game
Few games create a plot twist quite like this one.
At first, everyone’s working together.
Exploring a creepy old mansion.
Opening mysterious rooms.
Finding strange objects.
Then…
The Haunt begins.
Suddenly someone around the table is no longer your teammate.
They’re the villains.
And nobody saw it coming.
With dozens of different scenarios hidden inside the box, no two nights ever unfold quite the same way.
Every game feels like starring in your own horror film.
Hopefully one where you survive.
Best for: Groups that enjoy surprises, storytelling and dramatic accusations.
Horrified
The “finally… we all get to panic together” game
Not every game night needs a winner.
Sometimes surviving is enough.
In Horrified, the entire group works together to stop legendary monsters before they overrun the village.
Dracula.
The Mummy.
Frankenstein.
Each behaves completely differently, so every combination creates a brand-new puzzle to solve.
It’s tense without becoming overwhelming.
Strategic without becoming exhausting.
And one of the few cooperative games where everyone stays involved until the very end.
Also…
The artwork is absolutely gorgeous.
Best for: Families, Halloween game nights and people who prefer teamwork over trash talk.
Beautiful Strategy Games
The ones you’ll proudly leave on the coffee table.
Cascadia
The “this game somehow lowers my blood pressure” game
Some strategy games feel stressful.
Cascadia feels peaceful.
You’re slowly building forests, rivers and mountains while carefully placing wildlife exactly where it’ll score the most points.
It almost feels meditative.
Until someone takes the tile you’ve been waiting for.
Then suddenly…
Inner peace disappears.
Beautifully illustrated and deservedly awarded the Spiel des Jahres, Cascadia somehow balances strategy with relaxation in a way very few games manage.
Best for: Quiet evenings, nature lovers and players who enjoy thoughtful decisions.
Everdell
The “everyone immediately asks where you bought it” game
Let’s be honest.
Sometimes we buy a game because it looks incredible.
Everdell absolutely delivers.
The giant woodland tree instantly becomes the centrepiece of the table, while adorable animal citizens slowly build one of the deepest strategy games you’ll ever play.
Don’t let the artwork fool you.
Behind the cosy aesthetic is a game that rewards clever planning, careful timing and just enough adaptability when somebody unexpectedly steals your favourite card.
It’s beautiful.
It’s clever.
And it somehow gets prettier every time you play.
Best for: Collectors, strategy fans and anyone who appreciates games that are as stunning as they are satisfying.
Ticket to Ride: First Journey
The “gateway game everyone actually enjoys” game
Introducing people to modern board games can be surprisingly difficult.
Some are too complicated.
Others take forever to explain.
First Journey fixes both problems.
It keeps everything people love about Ticket to Ride while making the rules wonderfully approachable.
Games are quicker.
Turns move faster.
And newcomers finish their first game feeling like they genuinely understood what they were doing.
Which means they’re much more likely to ask,
“Can we play again?”
Exactly what you want from a gateway game.
Best for: Families, younger players and anyone beginning their board game collection.
✨ Final Thoughts
I don’t think a great game collection is about owning the most games.
It’s about owning the right ones.
The ones that come off the shelf again and again.
The ones friends ask about.
The ones that somehow become part of birthdays, holidays, rainy afternoons and lazy Sundays.
If even one of these becomes that game for your group…
I’d say it was worth every rupee.
So tell me—
if you could only add one of these games to your shelf this year…
Which one are you choosing?
Or is there another hidden gem every board game lover should know about?
🎲 Love discovering games you’ll actually play?
Subscribe to Enchanted Pen for weekly game recommendations, binge-worthy watchlists, book picks and original fiction—delivered straight to your inbox.
Leave a Reply